This Grammy-winning record from 1999 sports the balladic title single, which spent six weeks at the top of the U.S. Hot Country Songs chart. Its music video clocked in at #4 on CMT’s 100 Greatest Videos. The record scored Faith Hill a Grammy in 2001 for Best Country Album. Other popular singles from the record include “The Way You Love Me” and “Let’s Make Love.” The year after the album’s release, Hill and husband Tim McGraw embarked on their Soul2Soul tour, during which they performed songs from the record.  

You may also like: 100 best albums of the 21st century, according to critics